Talk:Queen Harpy/@comment-173.72.204.167-20131207034139/@comment-5299683-20140109054045

It would've been better if Luka was just allowed to choose who he wanted to marry, and treat that as a possibly canon ending. One of the things I love about SIlent Hill's endings is no matter which ending you get, either one is possible. There's no reason why Luka couldn't have a happy married life with most of the characters featured in these endings, not just Alice. Who did Luka ultimately pledge his heart to? Who knows? Who would you pick? That has a richer, more satisfying outcome than pressing X to die a dozen or so times..

Plus, this whole deal of putting lying to/putting Luka through an unneccessary trial made me want to punch several characters right in the face (mostly Tamamo). But it should be pointed out that by the time I got to this point, I was in a pretty bitter mood over watching Ilias fade away.