Talk:Angel Halo/@comment-26228098-20150707174025/@comment-26441687-20150709011836

It's stated by Tamamo that Heinrich got Angel Halo from a fallen angel at the beginning of his adventure.

Valkyrie states that Angel Halo was created by the first fallen angel(which is later specified to refer to Lucifina in the conversation with Michaela)

It's also stated by Lilim and Lilith that Black Alice wasn't defeated until after they were defeated.

It's demonstrated quite clearly that Heinrich had Angel Halo against Lilith and Lilim.

Michaela states that Ilias saving Black Alice was the last straw for Lucifina and that's when she rebelled.

So when you put it all together, yeah. It's kind of hard not to be a plot hole. The only way you can sort of get around it is by saying that Lucifina actually made it before she was a fallen angel and everyone just refers to her as a fallen angel because she's a fallen angel now and that doesn't necessarily mean that she was when she made the sword. But yeah, that's kind of weak.