Talk:Witch Hunt Village Sidequest/@comment-29895188-20160910112500

There's an achievement for going to one of them all the way to the boss area, accepting their offer to reconsider and defeat the other one, then reaching THAT one up to their boss area. So if you want to unlock that achievement and not waste time, attack the one you intend to recruit first before going to subdue the other person they want you to defeat.